Mahdawi v. Trump (Amicus Brief)
Summary
What this Case is About
Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian student at Columbia University and a lawful permanent resident, was arrested by immigration agents at his citizenship interview in Vermont, allegedly in retaliation for his pro-Palestine advocacy, including his part in campus divestment protests. A federal district court found he had raised a substantial First Amendment retaliation claim and granted him habeas relief, but a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit held that federal courts could not hear his challenge to his detention until his immigration proceedings were over.
When the full Second Circuit agreed to rehear the case, ADC filed an amicus brief in support of Mahdawi, joined by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, PEN America, the Rutherford Institute and the National Coalition Against Censorship. The brief argues that retaliatory detention inflicts an immediate First Amendment injury that later review cannot undo, that it chills the speech of noncitizens across the country, and that immigration courts within the executive branch cannot meaningfully judge constitutional claims against that same branch. Making noncitizens wait months or years for an Article III court would let the government punish protected speech with no timely remedy.
Case Files
Documents, press & coverage
Court documents
Court filings, most recent first.
Press Releases
ADC statements on the case, most recent first.
Your gift sustains the studies, the case files, and the classroom resources that keep this work credible.